ICC Trial Chamber rejects Ongwen leave to appeal oral decision on understanding charges


Trial Chamber IX has rejected the Defence’s request for leave to appeal the Chamber’s previous decision on Ongwen’s understanding of the nature of the charges, in the case of The Prosecutor v. Dominic Ongwen. This decision comes after Ongwen, at the opening of his trial on 6 December 2016, indicated that he did not understand the charges being brought against him – following which the Trial Chamber issued an oral decision finding that it is satisfied that Mr Ongwen understood the nature of the charges.

The Defence subsequently filed a leave to appeal this oral decision; raising the issue of whether the Trial Chamber was permitted to rely on Ongwen’s historical statements as the main basis of determining his understanding of the charges. In its rejection of this Defence request, the Trial Chamber corrected the Defence’s contention that the Chamber had used Ongwen’s prior statement as the “major basis” for its findings – pointing out that it took multiple other factors into consideration in assessing Ongwen’s understanding of the charges, including “the information provided to the accused after the issuance of the decision on the confirmation of the charges, the submissions and arguments made by the Defence in the course of the proceedings, the lack of sufficient substantiation for Defence’s allegations and, importantly, the accused’s statement made before the Chamber just prior to the issuance of the Impugned Decision.”

On this basis, the issue identified by the Defence was not found to arise from the substance of the Trial Chamber’s previous decision, thus is not an appealable issue pursuant to Article 82(1)(d) of the Rome Statute. (ICC TC Decision)

News Courtesy: ICL media review | News Uploader: Sharmin Jannat Bhutto

Disclaimer: This above article/news has been documented here from the source mentioned under the post & is one of the group activities which are being run by the ICR Foundation’s member as part of our media archiving project. The principal objective of this scheme is archiving, documenting, recording, and storing worldwide news events which are particularly related with the concept of International Criminal Law, i.e. War Crime, Genocide, Crimes against Humanity, Terrorism and other International Crimes. We are a non-profit research foundation with the intention to research on International Criminal Law for the awareness, betterment, establishing the rule of law & to end the culture of impunity across the world. It is also worth mentioning that all our archiving, documentation, recording & storing has been undertaken only for educational and research purposes. Individuals or institutions interested in utilising the content recorded in this chronicle of ours, especially those with the view of attaining some sort of financial gain from it, are strongly advised to contact or seek out the original source of the content they are interested in. Please Note, This disclaimer will not be applicable when the ICR Foundation will clearly mention that the document as their own Press release, Position Papers or any kind of statements.

Leave A Reply